Croquet England Logo
Croquet England Logo

CA beat the SCA 16-11 in Annual Match

[<<] [>>] by Fergus McInnes at Middlesbrough Croquet Club
31 Aug 2014 (International)

Three Scottish players - Brian Murdoch, Alan Wilson and Fergus McInnes - made their way down the A1 and were joined in Middlesbrough by three from further south - Sam Murray, David Magee and Derek Knight - in an attempt to wrest back the Glasgow Quaich from the English.

The teams appeared quite evenly matched, with the SCA handicaps at -0.5, 0, 0, 1.5, 3 and 3, and the CA at -0.5, 0.5, 1, 2, 2.5 and 4 - suggesting a slight advantage for the SCA if anything. The opening doubles round was in line with this, going 2-1 to the SCA. But in the singles things began going the wrong way for the Scots, and the score after the first day was 9-6 to the home side.

The first round on the second day increased the CA's lead to 13-8. The SCA could still turn it around to 13-14 (a good scoreline for a Scottish victory!) but only by winning all six games in the final round. This they failed to do, achieving only an equal split in the head-to-head games; and so the final result was CA 16, SCA 11.

I took notes on some of the games, and here is a selection of highlights.

Round 1, Waterfield & Killick v Murray & McInnes: Charles declined the opportunity of trying a standard triple, but then daftly attempted the 4-back peel straight, and then posthumously, with the result that he broke down on penult and 4-back. This meant that Sam got in and eventually had a break, but failing 2-back proved fatal for him and Fergus.

Round 2: Killick v McInnes included a classic Killick break, in which Andrew took off from a few yards west of hoop 2 to position at hoop 3, ran it (taking some wire) to just west of the end of A baulk, hit the ball at hoop 4 and continued to rover, rarely having a pioneer within five yards of his hoop. [His feat of running 3 to A baulk was helped by the fact that the hoop was set some 15 degrees out of correct north-south alignment.] Watts v Knight: at one point Derek was for 2-back and 4-back and Derek was for 2-back and 4-back... "And who's in play?" "Derek." (Derek Knight eventually pegged out after time had been called.) Errington v Murdoch: after completing his rover peel with a half-jump, Phil mistakenly took croquet immediately instead of taking his rush towards the peg, and Brian caught up from 1 and 3, crazily pegged Phil's ball out, rushed partner into rover after running it and failed the seven-yard peg-out through the hoop, and finally finished, just after time, after Phil missed the peg.

Round 3, Keen v Knight: Barry did two peels and attempted third (my predictive text suggested "suicide" here!) but couldn't make roquet after 4-back.

Round 4, Waterfield v McInnes: Fergus twice stuck in hoop 1 off Charles's ball and was a long way behind when time was called; his attempt to equalise required an all-round break and four peels with only three balls on the lawn, and he only got the first two hoops despite getting behind the ball near corner 4 and rushing it within a few yards of hoop 2. Had he managed to make the score -3 on time instead of -15 on time, this round would have had a complete set of small winning margins from 1 to 6.

Round 5, Keen v McInnes: Fergus went to 4-back in turn 7 after a supershot opening, Barry went to 4-back with a TPO attempt (the 4-back peel bounced off and he wisely abandoned it) a few turns later, Fergus set up for a triple but stuck in hoop 5, Barry did the 4-back peel on his partner ball after hoop 3 but broke down, and then the game got scrappy; Barry wanted to concede rather than play out the remaining 10 minutes or so, saying that he couldn't win if Fergus Aunt-Emma-ed him, but was prevented from doing so and nearly won! (And he had the cheek to complain about the rabbit run in 4-back that ended his last break!)

The hospitality of the Middlesbrough players to their visitors was exemplary: we enjoyed a good meal and several pints of Hill Climbing ale in the Vane Arms in Long Newton (Roger and Hilary Staples' local) on Friday evening, and a Chinese buffet in Middlesbrough on Saturday, and as well as being accommodated and fed by Andrew and Karen Killick I came away with some free apples from the trees in their garden. I hope we can do as well in providing for the CA team when they come to Scotland in 2015. I also hope we can regain the Quaich, which has been in the CA's hands for several years now!

Fergus McInnes

(CA names first)

Eugene Chang & Barry Keen lost to David Magee & Alan Wilson -24
Charles Waterfield & Andrew Killick beat Sam Murray & Fergus McInnes +19
Phil Errington & Derek Watts lost to Brian Murdoch & Derek Knight -13

Charles Waterfield lost to Sam Murray -13T (12-25)
Eugene Chang beat David Magee +26tp
Phil Errington lost to Brian Murdoch -1
Derek Watts lost to Derek Knight -5
Barry Keen beat Alan Wilson +20tp
Andrew Killick beat Fergus McInnes +18

Phil Errington lost to Sam Murray -22
Charles Waterfield beat David Magee +1T (22-21)
Eugene Chang beat Brian Murdoch +23
Barry Keen beat Derek Knight +6
Andrew Killick beat Alan Wilson +10
Derek Watts beat Fergus McInnes +25

Andrew Killick beat Sam Murray +1T (23-22)
Derek Watts beat David Magee +5T (25-20)
Barry Keen lost to Brian Murdoch -4
Eugene Chang beat Derek Knight +2
Phil Errington lost to Alan Wilson -6T (17-23)
Charles Waterfield beat Fergus McInnes +15T (22-7)

Eugene Chang lost to Sam Murray -8
Phil Errington beat David Magee +18
Charles Waterfield beat Brian Murdoch +26
Andrew Killick lost to Derek Knight -9
Derek Watts beat Alan Wilson +23
Barry Keen lost to Fergus McInnes -1T (19-20)

Match score: CA 16, SCA 11


Disclaimer: The opinions expressed on this news web page are those of the Editor and contributors. Croquet England is not responsible for statements other than those clearly identified as being made on its behalf. The full editorial policy is available online. The Web News Editor is the Croquet England Office.